PriceRoom

4 best hotels with a pool in Islamorada

By ·4 picks
Search hotels with a pool in Islamorada →
Editorial illustration — hotels with a pool in Islamorada
The brief

Why hotels with a pool, why here

Hotels with a pool in Islamorada are best understood as stays where the pool is more than an extra feature: it is a central part of the experience. In a destination known for its relaxed, coastal feel, a genuine pool hotel gives you an easy place to cool off after time on the water, unwind between outings, or simply keep the day unhurried. The best options combine a usable pool with a setting that suits the rhythm of the Keys, whether that means resort-style facilities, marina access, or a smaller, more laid-back property.

This list includes a mix of three- and four-star hotels, so there is something for different budgets and trip styles. The Islands of Islamorada and Three Waters Resort and Marina, Islamorada, a Tribute Portfolio Resort, suit travellers looking for a more polished resort stay, while places such as Pines & Palms Resort, La Jolla Resort, and Bayside Villas by Islander Resort offer a more relaxed base. Ragged Edge Resort & Marina and The Ocean View Inn & Pub add appeal for guests who want a practical stay with a pool and easy access to the area’s coastal atmosphere.

These hotels with a pool in Islamorada work well for couples, families, and anyone planning a slower Florida Keys break. A good fit means the pool is clean, inviting, and easy to use, with accommodation that matches the level of comfort you want from your stay.

The list

A selection of hotels to compare for your stay.

  1. 01
    ★★★

    Pines & Palms Resort

    Islamorada
    Waterfront Keys cottages near Indian Key, with a heated pool and ocean views.
    9 · 993 reviewsResortBeachfrontBeaches
    Check rates
  2. 02
    ★★★

    Sunset Inn

    Islamorada
    Relaxed motel-style stop in central Islamorada with a calm, inland pool area.
    8.5 · 1,169 reviewsCoastalCity centresHotel
    Check rates
  3. 03
    ★★★

    Bayside Villas by Islander Resort

    Islamorada
    Relaxed bayfront villas in Islamorada with full kitchens and a handy pool area.
    8.5 · 207 reviewsPet-friendlyBeachfrontBeaches
    Check rates
  4. 04
    ★★★

    The Ocean View Inn & Pub

    Islamorada
    Laid-back Islamorada stay by Windley Key, built around its pub and pool.
    8.4 · 245 reviewsBeachesHotelAmazing Views
    Check rates

Where the picks sit

Loading map…

What to know about hotels with a pool in Islamorada

What makes a hotel a true hotels with a pool option in Islamorada?

It should offer a proper, usable pool that adds real value to the stay, not just a token facility. In Islamorada, that usually means a pool that supports a relaxed Keys-style break.

Which area is best for staying in Islamorada?

For most visitors, the best area is the one that matches the type of trip you want, whether that is a resort-style stay, a marina setting, or a quieter base. The island-wide, coastal feel means many travellers prioritise access to the water and an easygoing atmosphere.

What is the typical price or level for hotels with a pool here?

The selection spans three- and four-star hotels, so the overall level is mid-range to upper mid-range. Prices will vary by season and property style, with resort hotels generally sitting higher than simpler stays.